Electrophilic aromatic sulfonation with SO3: concerted or classic S(E)Ar mechanism?

Gergana Koleva, Boris Galabov, Jing Kong, Henry F Schaefer, Paul von R Schleyer

Index: J. Am. Chem. Soc. 133(47) , 19094-101, (2011)

Full Text: HTML

Abstract

The electrophilic sulfonation of several arenes with SO(3) was examined by electronic structure computations at the M06-2X/6-311+G(2d,2p) and SCS-MP2/6-311+G(2d,2p) levels of theory. In contrast to the usual interpretations, the results provide clear evidence that in nonpolar media and in the absence of catalysts the mechanism of aromatic sulfonation with a single SO(3) is concerted and does not involve the conventionally depicted 1:1 σ complex (Wheland) intermediate. Moreover, the computed activation energy for the 1:1 process is unrealistically high; barriers for alternative 2:1 mechanisms involving attack by two SO(3) molecules are 12-20 kcal/mol lower! A direct 2:1 sulfonation mechanism, involving a single essential transition state, but no Wheland type intermediate, is preferred generally at MP2 as well as at M06-2X in isolation (gas phase) or in noncomplexing solvents (such as CCl(4) or CFCl(3)). However, in polar, higher dielectric SO(3)-complexing media, M06-2X favors an S(E)Ar mechanism for the 2:1 reaction involving a Wheland-type arene-(SO(3))(2) dimer intermediate. The reaction is slower in complexing solvents, since the association energy, e.g., with nitromethane, must be overcome. But, in accord with the experimental kinetics (second-order in SO(3)), attack by two sulfur trioxide molecules is still favored energetically over reaction with a single SO(3) in CH(3)NO(2). The theoretical results also reproduce the experimental reactivity and regioselectivity trends for benzene, toluene, and naphthalene sulfonation accurately.