The Poisson Statistics of Combinatorial Library Sampling Predict False Discovery Rates of Screening

Andrew B MacConnell, Brian M Paegel

Index: 10.1021/acscombsci.7b00061

Full Text: HTML

Abstract

Microfluidic droplet-based screening of DNA-encoded one-bead-one-compound combinatorial libraries is a miniaturized, potentially widely distributable approach to small molecule discovery. In these screens, a microfluidic circuit distributes library beads into droplets of activity assay reagent, photochemically cleaves the compound from the bead, then incubates and sorts the droplets based on assay result for subsequent DNA sequencing-based hit compound structure elucidation. Pilot experimental studies revealed that Poisson statistics describe nearly all aspects of such screens, prompting the development of simulations to understand system behavior. Monte Carlo screening simulation data showed that increasing mean library sampling (ε), mean droplet occupancy, or library hit rate all increase the false discovery rate (FDR). Compounds identified as hits on k > 1 beads (the replicate k class) were much more likely to be authentic hits than singletons (k = 1), in agreement with previous findings. Here, we explain this observation by deriving an equation for authenticity, which reduces to the product of a library sampling bias term (exponential in k) and a sampling saturation term (exponential in ε) setting a threshold that the k-dependent bias must overcome. The equation thus quantitatively describes why each hit structure’s FDR is based on its k class, and further predicts the feasibility of intentionally populating droplets with multiple library beads, assaying the micro-mixtures for function, and identifying the active members by statistical deconvolution.